I’m sharing my method for making 10 types of delicious holiday cookies from a single cookie dough. Each cookie is different and simple to prepare—perfect for holiday cookie boxes and festive gatherings!
Make 10 Holiday Cookies from 1 Dough!
Welcome to the holiday baking season—the time for warm treats, sharing, and celebrating with homemade cookies. I love baking a variety so family and friends can enjoy them all week. In this post I explain how to turn one butter cookie dough into ten different festive cookies: gingerbread men, snowballs, piped cookies, cut-outs, icebox cookies, Linzer (jam) cookies, and three soft cookies (chocolate chip, double chocolate, and molasses).
Why You’ll Love These Holiday Cookies
- Simple base dough: It comes together in 5–10 minutes by mixing the ingredients.
- High yield with less work: Make lots of cookies quickly without testing many different recipes.
- Versatile: If you’re short on time, pick one flavor and a few designs. You can make almost any cookie shape with this dough.
- Beautiful presentation: These cookies look festive and make a lovely homemade cookie box gift.
VIDEO: Watch How To Make the 10 Holiday Cookies!
Follow the step-by-step video tutorial to see each technique and make these cookies at home.
Enjoy the video and subscribe to Aya’s channel for more baking tips.
Make the cookie dough
The base cookie dough
Prepare one batch of the base butter cookie dough (see the referenced base recipe). Divide the dough into portions to create three flavored variations: vanilla, gingerbread, and chocolate.
Aya’s Quick Tip💡
The dough will be soft at room temperature. If you plan to roll it right away, place it between parchment sheets to prevent sticking. Otherwise chill until firmer.
1. Vanilla cookie dough
Mix vanilla extract into a portion of the base dough. Chill as needed before shaping.
2. Gingerbread cookie dough
Add molasses, spices (ginger, cinnamon, allspice, clove), and a little all-purpose flour to a portion of the base dough. Mix until uniform, then chill.
3. Chocolate cookie dough
Stir cocoa powder into a portion of the base dough and mix until consistent. Chill if needed before shaping.
With the flavored doughs ready, it’s time to shape and bake ten different cookies.
Make 10 Holiday Cookies
Snowball cookies
Fold toasted pecans into vanilla dough, chill so you can roll into balls, then bake. Once cooled, roll in powdered sugar to finish.
Piped cookies
Pipe vanilla dough into rosettes or rounds using a star tip. Chill before baking. After baking, pipe melted dark chocolate into the center.
Wreath cookies
Roll vanilla dough between parchment and chill. Use two circular cutters to create a ring. Decorate with dried cranberries and sprinkles, chill again, and bake. Optionally thread a decorative string through each cookie once cooled.
Mini chocolate chip cookies
To vanilla dough add brown sugar and baking soda, mix in mini chips. Chill, portion into 15 g balls, press flat, top with extra chips, and bake.
Mini gingerbread cookies (molasses cookies)
To gingerbread dough add brown sugar and baking soda, chill, roll into 15 g balls, coat in granulated sugar, then bake. Optionally dip or drizzle with white and dark chocolate for a marbled finish.
Gingerbread man cookies
Roll gingerbread dough between parchment, chill, cut into shapes, use a toothpick to draw faces and add sprinkles for details. Chill again if needed, then bake.
Mini chocolate cookies
To chocolate dough add brown sugar, baking soda, and milk. Chill, shape 15 g balls, bake, and optionally dip in melted dark chocolate for a glossy finish.
Linzer cookies (Jam cookies)
Roll chocolate dough, chill, cut pairs of shapes (one with a center cutout). Bake, then pipe jam on the bottom cookie, dust powdered sugar on the top, and sandwich together.
Star cookies
Use the cut-out stars saved from the Linzer cookies. Brush with egg white, add sprinkles, chill briefly, and bake until lightly golden.
Dried fruits & nuts icebox cookies
Combine leftover dough with diced dried fruit and toasted nuts. Shape into a log, freeze, brush with egg white, roll in granulated sugar, chill, then slice and bake.
How to bake them
Chill cut-out and piped dough until just before baking. Cold dough spreads less and holds its shape better. Freezing briefly helps the best results.
Bake in a preheated oven at 345°F (174°C) for 6–15 minutes. Time depends on cookie size, thickness, and your oven.
- Adjust time and temperature for your oven and cookie size.
- For soft cookies: Shorter bake times keep them chewy—small cookies may only need 6–7 minutes. They firm up as they cool. Molasses cookies usually bake fastest; chocolate cookies may take longer. Remove batches as they finish and continue baking the rest if mixed on one tray.
- For cut-outs and piped cookies: Bake until edges show a light golden caramelization for a crisp texture.
One batch makes a generous number of cookies—adjust quantities and make more batches as needed for gatherings or gifts.
Frequently Asked Questions
Keep cookies in an airtight container up to 4 days at room temperature or up to 2 weeks in the refrigerator. Consume sooner for optimal freshness. In humid climates, adding a food-safe desiccant can help keep crunchy cookies crisp. Soft cookies dry out faster—store them gently and avoid overbaking.
Wrap dough tightly and refrigerate for 4–5 days, or freeze for several months.
No—because it contains eggs, it’s safer to keep dough refrigerated or frozen.
Yes—this base dough is very versatile. Experiment with flavors, mix-ins, shapes, and decorations to create your own cookie box.
More Holiday Cookie Recipes
If you enjoy seasonal baking, try other cookie recipes to build a varied cookie box.
- Gingerbread cookies
- Christmas cookie box
- Four classic soft cookies from one dough
- Fall cookie box
Other Holiday Dessert Recipes
Here are a few other seasonal desserts to try alongside your cookies: shortbread, pumpkin spice bread, apple hand pies, and classic apple pie.
Did you try the recipe?
Leave your feedback in the comment section below—I’d love to hear how these cookies worked for your holiday celebrations.
Thank you! – Aya
10 Holiday Cookies from 1 Dough (Holiday Cookie Box)
Pin Recipe